Reptired wrote:
I think you have got a very good point here, I would argue that the ages you stated are too old. If you look at young children from the time they are able to verbalise effectively you hear a lot of questions, mainly "WHY?", the other thing you seem to hear is "IT'S NOT FAIR!".
Well, I just picked the age at random, really. But I believe that inherently an 8 year-old will understand that killing is wrong. Of course, a 28 year-old understands this too, but they have absorbed all the necessary propaganda and social programming to ensure that they react in the right way when it actually happens in a certain context (some manage to escape this, but all too few). If you show people images from Iraq of dead bodies, mangled children, birth deformities etc, people will almost without exception react in horror and find it completely unpalatable, so that shows that the basic recognition that this is wrong and morally repugnant is still intact. Just somehow people are unable to assess correctly when slaughter is justified to them in a certain way, in a certain context.
I would say as well that it’s particularly something in the male psyche that is being targeted. There has been some effort in the States to recruit women to the armed forces and even the front line, but I would be very surprised if this is ever extended seriously, because the percentage of women that are willing to shoot guns at people and drop bombs is incredibly trivial. So to give a slightly crass example, young boys often play with guns, they often have that basic aggression in them, whereas girls play with dolls. How often have you seen an 8 year-old girl express the desire to play with a gun, or to play fight? But even at that age, boys will still show remorse if someone gets hurt, but this basic instinct, which it could be argued served evolutionary purposes, can be exploited by people in positions of power.
Thus, the social programming simply works much better on a certain type of young men, many of whom later greatly regret what they’ve done when they’re forced to confront it in the cold light of day, and perhaps once their chemical make-up and balance has changed with time (ie. less testosterone, for example). There is a quotation in the video game GTA4, where the main character states that “war is when the young and stupid are tricked by the old and bitter into killing each other”. I wouldn’t say that’s entirely true, but thematically it is pretty accurate.
Thank you for posting the Gatto videos BTW, someone has recommended his books to me before, they're on my reading list.
psketti wrote:
I more or less said those words just the other night although in my opinion, it's the system that breaks them.... the family and social environment just all fall into place as part of the process.
And, of course, the family and social environment is a product of the same system, so the people that populate it don't realise that the values they're passing on are skewed. The authority figures and people that the child look up to have all been through the same process, so consequently they don't even recongise that anything is awry.